Hauntings at Lizzie Borden House

October is the month for haunted houses and spooky attractions. But in some locations like Salem Massachusetts, hauntings are no joke. The all but real sinister and evil past lingers on to haunt the living all year round. If you’ve been to Salem and checked out all the haunts and haven’t yet had your fill, then you’ll want to drive 76 miles south to a place called Fall River. At the address 230 2nd Street, Fall River, MA you will find the Lizzie Borden House.

Lizzie Borden House
Photo by Bootbear/Flickr

Lizzie Andrew Borden (July 19, 1860 – June 1, 1927) was a New England spinster/librarian woman who gained notoriety and disgrace in 1892 after being put on trial and acquitted for the heinous ax murders of her father and stepmother in the small community of Fall River, Massachusetts.

Lizzie Borden is still laughing about getting away with murder!

Photo source Wikipedia

The murders and following trials by both the courts and media became a cause for widespread controversy and heated debates. The fame of the incident has endured till today, and although Lizzie Borden was acquitted, she is still to this day believed to be guilty of these gruesome crimes. No one else was ever arrested or tried, and she has remained notorious in American history. The debate over the identity of the killer or killers continues to this day.

The house was originally built in 1845, and in 1874 Andrew Borden bought it so he could be closer to his bank and thriving businesses. Although the house was in an affluent area and despite Borden’s wealth, he was miserly and did not have modern features like plumbing in his home.

Lizzie’s mother, Sarah Anthony (Morse) Borden passed away on March 26, 1863, and almost 3 years later, Andrew marries Abby Durfee Gray on June 6, 1865. Here is where Lizzie’s misery begins.

With Andrew gifting some property to various members of Abby’s family, it only increased the already enormous tension between the sisters and their father. Livid about this generous gift, the sister challenged their father and demanded some rental property. Their father complied by selling them one of his rental homes for $1. He purchased the property back for $5,000.

The evening before the murders, Lizzie’s and Emma’s uncle, John Vinnicum Morse, arrived to discuss business matters with Andrew and was invited to stay for a few more days. Some have theorized that heated conversations, especially about property transfer, may have been the tipping point in an already uneasy situation.

Lizzie Borden
Photo source Wikipedia

During the fateful morning of August 4, 1892, Andrew Jackson Borden and his wife Abby Durfee Borden were murdered in their home. Only Lizzie and her maid Bridget Sullivan were home at the time. One wonders how they two could not have heard any scuffles or screams. Emma Borden and John Morse, the sisters’ uncle and brother of Andrew Borden’s first wife, John Morse, were away from the house during the time of the murders.

Let’s walk through that morning. Around 7 a.m, Andrew Borden and his wife have breakfast with John Morse. At 8:45 am, Mr. Morse leaves the house to return at 11:30 a.m. Around 8:50 am Lizzie comes downstairs to have breakfast alone. At 9:15 a.mMr. Borden goes downtown for a shave and to make his usual rounds. Around 10:45 a.m. Mr. Borden returns not feeling well. Then at 11:05-11:10, Lizzie tells Bridget the maid Mr. Borden has been killed! Neighbors come to consol Lizzie, but it was short-lived as the maid discovers Abby Borden has also been murdered.

Despite what this infamous poem states, Abby received around 18 – 22 direct hits to the back of her head until she was dead, and Andrew was struck 10 or 11 times with a hatchet-like weapon. After a 13 day trial, Lizzie Borden was acquitted of all charges and released from jail. Apparently, Lizzie and her sister went back to the house for a very brief time and then Lizzie bought a fashionable Queen Anne Victorian mansion in the upscale neighborhood called the Hill. Lizzie lived here until her passing on June 1, 1927.

Today, the Lizzie Borden House is a bed and breakfast/museum where brave guests can spend the night. Guests from all over the world are eager to experience the Lizzie Borden house, especially for the re-enactment every August. Is the house haunted? Yes!

Room inside Lizzie Borden's home
Photo courtesy Flickr Amy Meredith

Late at night, many guests have reported hearing Lizzie cackle at the top of the stairs, very near the room where Abby was murdered. But Lizzie’s is not the only spirit haunting the home. Many hear footsteps upstairs walking from room to room, hearing voices, seeing shadow figures and some have been physically attacked. A staff member who stayed there one night felt she was not welcome and woke the next morning to the rocking chair facing her bed like someone watched her sleep.

Room inside Lizzie Borden's home
Photo courtesy of Massachusetts Travel & Tourism

There are the spirits of three children, Irene, Henry, and Sally, haunt the third floor and many who stay at the bed and breakfast have experienced childlike activity. Who are these three children? Back in the 1840s, the land was a pear orchard that was owned by the people adjacent to Lizzie’s property. There was also a well on the property. The wife of the property owner was suffering from post-partum depression and she brought her three children, 2 toddlers, and one baby to the well and dropped them in. Afterward, she went home and slit her throat with her husband’s straight-edge razor.

Both Abby and Andrew are said to walk the grounds and the maid Bridget Sullivan screams for help in the darkest hour of the night. The basement is said to be home to one or more evil entities, but no quests are willing to venture down there. But, you’re welcome to make a reservation and investigate yourself.